A patient insists on a treatment that the physician knows is ineffective and potentially harmful. What is the best response?
Show answer and explanation
Correct answer: Refuse and explain evidence-based reasoning
Autonomy does not obligate physicians to provide harmful or ineffective treatments. Nonmaleficence requires refusing while explaining the reasoning.
Practice all 20 Medical Ethics and Professional Behavior questions
Keep practicing
More Medical Ethics and Professional Behavior questions
- A competent patient refuses a life-saving blood transfusion due to religious beliefs. What is the physician’s most appropriate action?
- A physician tells a patient that a procedure has no risks, even though minor risks exist. Which ethical principle is violated?
- A patient requests that the physician not disclose a cancer diagnosis to her family. What is the best response?
- A physician gives extra time and care to well-insured patients while rushing through visits with uninsured patients. Which ethical principl…
- A physician withholds treatment options because she assumes the patient cannot afford them. What principle does this violate?
- A surgeon discloses a surgical error to the patient and explains the next steps for management. Which ethical principle is demonstrated?